A Pair of Guys Lost: A New Musical Fringe Review, by Andrea Noga (AYTC).

Are you a Canadian who’s tired of hearing about American politics? I get it. However, before you swear it off completely, consider if this show might be right for you.

Pair of Guys Lost is a new musical by local theatre artist David Son (Book, music, lyrics, director, choreographer, “Steve”). The show follows “Adam”, the first man (or is he?) on Earth and the #1 worshipper of God, who happens to resemble a certain American president. However, everything begins to change when the angels send Adam a partner to live with on Earth and together they begin to unravel the lies of the so-called “paradise” they live in. It is a both a political statement and an exciting, funny, updated version of the creation story.

Pair of Guys Lost offers a large (for Fringe) ensemble cast, and features some of the strongest vocals I’ve heard at Fringe 2025, especially from cast member Nicole Gaskell. Gaskell portrays Kelly-Anne, (where have I heard that name before?) the woman-in-waiting to God– however, we soon realize that Kelly-Anne is really the one pulling all the strings. Gaskell’s Kelly-Anne is sickeningly evil, and her belty villain song is the standout number of the show. The trio of gossipy angels (Sika Clarke, Erin McLean, and Kaitlyn Power) also deliver impressive harmonies and strong characterization.

The original score of Pair of Guys Lost offers something exciting for Fringe, with techno beats that make you count down the days until a cast recording releases. While the music spans a few genres in a way that starts to feel disjointed, there are some solid feats of composition, especially for the slower numbers. The original script also offers interesting viewpoints and political commentary, if not as much as I expected. When I saw the character of God was clearly inspired by President Donald Trump, I expected politics to take center stage in the musical. While they still feature prominently, the show critiques religion mainly and the Trump-like character only appears a few times. Within the premise, I do believe there were more opportunities to integrate direct political commentary and avoid having the addition of American politics feel like a gimmick. Still, the show has a clear perspective and sticks to it throughout.

John Milton wrote “All is not lost, the unconquerable will, and study of revenge, immortal hate, and the courage never to submit or yield.” in Paradise Lost. Pair of Guys Lost has a similar message. Even in the face of oppressive politics and pressure to succumb, there is always the option to follow what you believe is right. This message may be delivered through vogueing and various wig changes, but it is delivered nonetheless. Pair of Guys Lost is a new musical that truly feels innovative and exciting, and that means a lot.

Pair of Guys Lost: A New Musical plays at the Mile Zero Dance Studio.