Jessie MacAlpine Shearer

This show is an extraordinary celebration of long-term love, commitment, and the quiet ways we continue choosing one another through life's many changes. It is deeply funny, profoundly wise, and incredibly human. It beautifully captures the reality that lasting relationships aren't built on perfection but they're sustained by the willingness to keep showing up, even when it's difficult, forgive quickly, and to continually rediscover one another through each season of life.

The humour is distinctly British, and the production strikes the perfect balance of making it accessible without ever diluting its charm or intelligence. I love how theatre brings us all to laugh together progressively louder as the show goes on. Both actors deliver impeccable performances, with flawless comic timing and remarkable emotional depth. They effortlessly transport the audience through each decade of the Elvie & Alfie’s journey, making every stage of their relationship feel authentic and earned.

I absolutely loved the ending. It brought me to tears as it spoke so truthfully to the depth of commitment in marriage: to be truly seen, deeply known, and completely accepted as we grow and change together. The end holds the sadness of when that all ends and becomes a memory. This is one of those rare productions that doesn't just entertain; it leaves you reflecting on your own life, your own relationships, and the quiet beauty of choosing love again and reflecting on the memories we’ll have in the end.

This production feels like a university show in the best sense as you can see raw talent and a lot of potential on stage. There are several standout performances, and some of the dialogue is genuinely compelling.

Where I think the show could grow is in its overall focus and emotional journey. I found myself wanting a clearer central message and a character whose arc I could really invest in. While the play explores interesting ideas such as small town hockey culture, the end of an athletic career, and fighting as a source of identity or purpose; it felt like there were too many themes competing for attention. As a result, I left unsure of what the show ultimately wanted me to take away.

With a stronger throughline and more defined character growth, I think these powerful moments could come together into a much more impactful and memorable experience. The talent is clearly there, and refining the narrative focus would allow it to shine even more.